Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

Peter Dutton wants American anti-mafia laws to take on the CFMEU. Could they work in Australia?

  • Written by: Anna Sergi, Professor in Criminology, University of Essex
A Teamsters union emblem with two horse heads attached to a grey wall.

In June 1988, the Reagan administration launched the most important US labour case[1] of the past half-century.

The government alleged the Italian-American mafia – La Cosa Nostra[2] – had effectively taken over the nation’s largest and most influential private sector union, the International Brotherhood of Teamsters[3] (IBT).

A civil suit began under the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act[4] (RICO) in a bid to prosecute officials and wrest control of the union from the country’s most powerful criminal syndicate.

Fast forward to Australia in March 2025. Opposition Leader Peter Dutton is floating RICO-style organised crime powers against the militant construction union, the CFMEU.

‘Modern day mafia’

The proposal follows new allegations of corruption and misconduct, including violence against women[5], and union-linked crime infiltration of Victorian government projects. The revelations suggest previous political and police efforts to clean up the CFMEU have failed.

Dutton is drawing a direct parallel between the modern-day CFMEU and the mafia- dominated[6] Teamsters of the 1980s.

This is the biggest corruption scandal in Australian history. The CFMEU is a modern-day mafia operation. The culture of criminality and corruption is so entrenched, and it will never change, especially under the weak and incompetent Albanese Labor government.

Dutton says if he is elected prime minister at the coming election, he will introduce national racketeering laws[7] to tackle the alleged union corruption. Notably, he makes specific reference[8] to the US “anti-mafia laws”.

US ‘takedown’ laws

Is Dutton on the right track? Could anti-racketeering laws work in Australia?

They might, but it is critical we clarify some of the confusion around them, starting with the “mafia” reference.

Although it is correct to say the RICO Act was passed in 1970 with a specific target[9] in mind, the families of the Italian-American La Cosa Nostra, the act itself does not mention the mafia.

A Teamsters union emblem with two horse heads attached to a grey wall.
The Coalition is drawing inspiration from the US racketeering laws which were introduced to tackle the mafia infiltration of the Teamsters union. Mark Van Scyoc/Shutterstock[10]

In practice, RICO adds the concept of “criminal enterprise” to a prosecution. It requires proof of a “pattern” of racketeering activity and its relationship to an enterprise, in addition to proving the individual crimes alleged. This made RICO particularly apt to tackle the involvement of mafia-type organised crime in labour racketeering[11].

Crucially, RICO can be applied both to organised crime groups (associations-in-fact) and other organisations, including lawful ones (associations-by-law). This made it possible to stretch the applicability[12] of RICO well beyond its intended use, with mixed results.

Italy passed similar anti-mafia laws[13] in 1982. The Italian legislation is specific about the behaviours of mafia-type associations including intimidation and corruption.

CFMEU in the dock

Anti-mafia legislation could work in Australia, but not if it’s just a direct transfer of the US RICO laws. Dutton needs to shift his focus[14] and define similar, but Australia-specific, laws.

Again, Italian and US legislation focus on criminal behaviour by enterprise.

By contrast, the existing proscribed association laws[15] in Australia focus on identity of organised criminals, including “bikie” gangs, or on individual participation in organised crime activities, such as drug trafficking.

The different focus takes us back to the CFMEU. Here, the problem is not just the union. All the alleged racketeering[16] in recent years also involved certain building companies, as well as various gangsters and bikies. Union bosses seemed to act like gangsters[17] and the actual gangsters morphed into industrial relations “consultants” employed by major companies.

When well-known gangland figures[18], such as Mick Gatto[19] provide mediation and protection services to an industry through intimidation[20], and the industry normalises kickbacks[21], then we are in a racketeering and mafia scenario.

Australian racketeering laws

As has already been noted[22], there are practical problems passing a new racketeering law.

Both the Italian and US regimes required a complete overhaul of criminal procedures and allocation of resources.

Peter Dutton's head, wearing glasses, in front of a blue banner
Peter Dutton says the CFMEU is the biggest corruption scandal in Australian history. Diego Fedele/AAP[23]

The Australian legal landscape for combating organised crime is complicated by its federal structure. This means there are nine jurisdictions with significant diversity in criminal laws.

However, a new federal offence could be imagined within the legislative powers of the Commonwealth’s section 51[24]. It would aim at protecting trade, commerce, and even external affairs. It could strengthen the capability of federal agencies to investigate corruption and organised crime.

But any new federal offence must define the concept of criminal enterprise. This would be an association that engages in a pattern of behaviours, such as drug trafficking, extortion, money laundering, and corruption.

Beyond the union case, the new offence would also apply to the Australian ‘ndrangheta[25], the mafia organisation that operates transnationally[26] across Europe, North America and in this country.

A federal offence targeting the behaviours of criminal enterprises goes beyond the actions of individuals. But such a response to both organised crime and corruption in Australia should be in line with existing Commonwealth frameworks.

Directly importing US laws is not an option for Dutton. However, there are ways to draft RICO-styled laws that could still work in Australia and clean up the CFMEU, once and for all.

References

  1. ^ labour case (www.journals.uchicago.edu)
  2. ^ La Cosa Nostra (www.ojp.gov)
  3. ^ International Brotherhood of Teamsters (teamster.org)
  4. ^ Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (law.justia.com)
  5. ^ violence against women (www.theage.com.au)
  6. ^ mafia- dominated (www.afr.com)
  7. ^ national racketeering laws (theconversation.com)
  8. ^ specific reference (www.abc.net.au)
  9. ^ target (link.springer.com)
  10. ^ Mark Van Scyoc/Shutterstock (www.shutterstock.com)
  11. ^ labour racketeering (scholarship.law.nd.edu)
  12. ^ applicability (www.emerald.com)
  13. ^ anti-mafia laws (journals.sagepub.com)
  14. ^ shift his focus (journals.sagepub.com)
  15. ^ proscribed association laws (www.alrc.gov.au)
  16. ^ racketeering (www.theage.com.au)
  17. ^ seemed to act like gangsters (www.theage.com.au)
  18. ^ well-known gangland figures (www.theage.com.au)
  19. ^ Mick Gatto (www.smh.com.au)
  20. ^ intimidation (www.theage.com.au)
  21. ^ industry normalises kickbacks (www.theage.com.au)
  22. ^ noted (www.theage.com.au)
  23. ^ Diego Fedele/AAP (photos.aap.com.au)
  24. ^ section 51 (www.aph.gov.au)
  25. ^ ‘ndrangheta (journals.sagepub.com)
  26. ^ operates transnationally (www.aspistrategist.org.au)

Authors: Anna Sergi, Professor in Criminology, University of Essex

Read more https://theconversation.com/peter-dutton-wants-american-anti-mafia-laws-to-take-on-the-cfmeu-could-they-work-in-australia-252643

The Weekend Times Magazine

Diamonds & Why They Are The Popular Choice For Any Occasion Here In Australia

Diamonds have been an incredibly popular gem for many years now and they continue to be so even now in 2024. It seems like the perfect jewel to choose for...

What is Medicines Optimisation and Why is it Important?

Medicines optimisation is a patient-focused approach to safe and effective medication use that helps people get the best possible outcomes from their treatments. Rather than simply ensuring patients take their...

Body Contouring Melbourne: Sculpting Confidence with Safe and Effective Treatments

Achieving your ideal body shape often takes more than just diet and exercise. For those looking to enhance their natural contours, body contouring Melbourne clinics offer advanced treatments designed to reduce...

Turning fashion into power - Beauty with Brains

During this unfortunate time of our lives there’s a hidden gem business which keeps the hopes up for many lives of women of all walks of life. Fashion...

Trading With Quantum AI: A How-To Guide

Quantum AI can be used in any country where retail CFD trading is legal. The site does warn that registration spots are limited, so your first try might not be successful. If...

When AEC IT breaks, It Rarely Looks Like IT

AEC businesses rarely lose time to one dramatic outage. What hurts more are the small, repeat delays that show up right when pressure is highest. The drawing set stalls, the...

Brisbane Compensation Lawyers for Work Injury Damages

Suffering a work-related injury can turn your life upside down. The physical pain, emotional stress, and financial uncertainty can feel overwhelming. If you’re in Brisbane and facing this situation, finding...

Weekend getaways from Perth

You Are in Perth, Australia and You Want to Get Away for the Weekend: What Are the Options? Perth is one of the most isolated cities in the world, but that...

Eradicate Sugar To Aid Good Mental Health

It’s R U OK Day tomorrow, Thursday 10 September, the national day of action for people to check in with their peers, family and friends to see if they’re ok.  Twenty...

hacklink esim new zealandBetimgrandpashabet girişzlibraryz libraryjojobetcialis 20 mg fiyat