Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

Venezuela, Gaza, Ukraine: is the UN failing?

  • Written by: Juliette McIntyre, Senior Lecturer in Law, Adelaide University

The United Nations turned 80 in October last year; a venerable age for the most significant international organisation the world has ever seen.

But events of recent years – from last weekend’s Trumpian military action[1] to seize Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro and Russia’s unlawful invasion of Ukraine[2] in 2022, to the ongoing humanitarian catastrophe[3] in Gaza – represent major challenges to the UN system.

Many are now asking whether the United Nations has any future at all if it cannot fulfil its first promise of maintaining international peace and security[4].

Has the UN reached the end of its lifespan?

The UN Security Council

The organ of the UN that plays the main role maintaining peace and security is the UN Security Council[5].

Under the rules established by the UN Charter[6], military action – the use of force – is only lawful if it has been authorised by a resolution from the UN Security Council (as outlined in Article 42[7] of the Charter), or if the state in question is acting in self-defence.

Self-defence is governed by strict rules requiring it to be in response to an armed attack (Article 51[8]). Even then, self-defence is lawful only until the Security Council has stepped in to restore international peace and security.

The Security Council is made up of 15 member states[9]:

  • five permanent (China, France, Russia, the United Kingdom and the United States – also known as the P5)

  • ten non-permanent members elected for two-year terms.

Resolutions require nine affirmative votes and no veto from any permanent member, giving the P5 decisive control over all action on peace and security.

This was set up expressly to prevent the UN from being able to take action against the major powers (the “winners” of the second world war), but also to allow them to act as a balance to each other’s ambitions.

This system only works, however, when the P5 agree to abide by the rules.

Venezuela, Gaza, Ukraine: is the UN failing?
The permanent representative of Venezuela to the United Nations, Samuel Moncada, speaks during an emergency meeting of the UN Security Council after the recent US military operation in Venezuela. EPA/DEREK FRENCH[10]

Could the UN veto system be reformed?

As aptly demonstrated by the Russians and Americans in recent years, the veto power can render the Security Council effectively useless, no matter how egregious the breach of international law.

For that reason, the veto is often harshly criticised[11].

As one of us (Tamsin Paige) has explained previously[12], however, self-serving use of the veto power (meaning when a member state uses its veto power to further its own interests) may be politically objectionable but it is not legally prohibited.

The UN Charter[13] imposes no enforceable limits on veto use.

Nor is there any possibility of a judicial review[14] of the Security Council at the moment.

And herein lies one of the most significant and deliberate design flaws of the UN system.

The charter places the P5 above the law, granting them not only the power to veto collective action, but also the power to veto any attempt at reform.

Reforming the UN Security Council veto is thus theoretically conceivable – Articles 108 and 109[15] of the charter allow for it – but functionally impossible[16].

Dissolving and reconstituting the UN under a new charter is the only structural alternative.

This, however, would require a level of global collectivism that presently does not exist. One or more of the P5 would likely block any reform or redesign that would see the loss of their veto power.

An uncomfortable truth

It does, therefore, appear as though we are witnessing the collapse of the UN-led international peace and security system in real time.

The Security Council cannot – by design – intervene when the P5 (China, France, Russia, the UK and US) are the aggressors.

But focusing only on the Security Council risks missing much of what the UN actually does, every day, largely out of sight.

Despite its paralysis when it comes to great-power conflict, the UN is not a hollow institution.

The Secretariat[17], for instance, supports peacekeeping and political missions and helps organise international conferences and negotiations.

The Human Rights Council[18] monitors and reports on human rights compliance.

UN-administered agencies[19] coordinate humanitarian relief and deliver life-saving aid.

The UN machinery touches on everything from health to human rights to climate and development, performing functions that no single state can replicate alone.

None of this work requires Security Council involvement, but all of it depends on the UN’s institutional infrastructure (of which the Security Council is an integral part).

The uncomfortable truth is we have only one real choice at present: a deeply flawed global institution, or none at all.

The future of the UN may simply be one of sheer endurance, holding together what can still function and waiting for political conditions to change.

We support it not because it works perfectly, or even well, but because losing it would be much worse.

Should we work towards a better system that doesn’t reward the powerful by making them unaccountable? Absolutely.

But we shouldn’t throw out all of the overlooked good the UN does beyond the Security Council’s chambers because of the naked hypocrisy and villainy of the P5.

References

  1. ^ military action (theconversation.com)
  2. ^ unlawful invasion of Ukraine (theconversation.com)
  3. ^ humanitarian catastrophe (www.aljazeera.com)
  4. ^ maintaining international peace and security (www.un.org)
  5. ^ UN Security Council (main.un.org)
  6. ^ UN Charter (www.un.org)
  7. ^ Article 42 (legal.un.org)
  8. ^ Article 51 (legal.un.org)
  9. ^ member states (main.un.org)
  10. ^ EPA/DEREK FRENCH (photos.aap.com.au)
  11. ^ harshly criticised (news.un.org)
  12. ^ explained previously (dro.deakin.edu.au)
  13. ^ UN Charter (www.un.org)
  14. ^ judicial review (www.jstor.org)
  15. ^ Articles 108 and 109 (legal.un.org)
  16. ^ but functionally impossible (theconversation.com)
  17. ^ Secretariat (www.un.org)
  18. ^ Human Rights Council (www.ohchr.org)
  19. ^ agencies (www.un.org)

Authors: Juliette McIntyre, Senior Lecturer in Law, Adelaide University

Read more https://theconversation.com/venezuela-gaza-ukraine-is-the-un-failing-272703

The Weekend Times Magazine

6 things that can go wrong if your iron isn't adequate before falling pregnant

Preconception care involves making sure you have adequate supply of all the nutrients essential to the health of the sperm and ova (egg) and to fetal development. Preconception also involves...

Aussies get budget savvy with surge in deferred payment of bills

Deferit co-founders Mat Blas and Jonty Hirsowitz Deferit, a payment platform exclusively focused on helping people pay their bills on time, has released new data on the huge uptake of its...

Why More Perth Homeowners Are Choosing Bidets for Modern Bathrooms

Bathroom renovations are no longer just about choosing stylish tiles, modern vanities and attractive tapware. Homeowners are increasingly considering how their bathrooms can support better hygiene, everyday comfort and long-term...

Does Sydney Australia Have a Good Nightlife Scene?

In the last several years, Sydney's nightlife has changed dramatically. The New South Wales state government adopted Draconian lockout regulations in 2014, forcing city center venues to close their doors...

Body Contouring Melbourne: Sculpting Confidence with Safe and Effective Treatments

Achieving your ideal body shape often takes more than just diet and exercise. For those looking to enhance their natural contours, body contouring Melbourne clinics offer advanced treatments designed to reduce...

Men’s style: where to buy it and how to build it

Most men are not taught style. They are taught how to work, drive, earn money and solve problems. Fashion and presentation are often treated as secondary concerns, something instinctive that men...

The Best Camera Smartphones for 2021

Everyone is a photographer these days, and it is no surprise, given that the top camera phones on the market are capable of fighting head-on with luxury compact cameras and...

Tammy Hembrow's Saski Collection re-launches Mesh Collection

The new range from fitness expert Tammy Hembrow’s clothing range Saski Collection has dropped its original Mesh Collection for the second time.   The new luxury athleisure label’s collection, which is worn by the likes of J Lo and available...

The Importance Of Choosing Quality Boat Supplies For Safety, Performance And Enjoyable Boating

Whether you are a recreational boater, an angler or someone who spends frequent weekends exploring the shoreline, investing in reliable boat supplies is essential. Quality supplies improve the functionality of your...

hacklink esim new zealandBetimgrandpashabet girişzlibraryz libraryjojobetcialis 20 mg fiyat