Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

Is Australia’s terrorism definition still fit for purpose?

  • Written by: Keiran Hardy, Associate Professor, Griffith Criminology Institute, Griffith University

With the alleged attempted bombing at Perth’s Invasion Day protest now declared a terrorist act[1], the release of coronial findings[2] into the Bondi Westfield stabbing, and ever-growing fears around hate crime and extremism[3], there’s a difficult question to grapple with: what is terrorism?.

An immediate answer is found in Australia’s legal definition[4]. However, this was created back in 2002, and the global threat environment has since evolved many times over.

While organised terrorist groups such as al-Qaeda and Islamic State persist, the threat landscape is now variegated. There are neo-Nazis[5], incels[6], sovereign citizens[7] and more[8] on the horizon.

Lone actors[9] are a particular challenge, as they do not always fit neatly into an ideological box. They can decide to act very quickly, and it can be difficult for agencies to know who they are and what level of risk they pose.

Violence can be driven in part by mental health crises[10]. This is why contemporary threats are sometimes called “mixed, unstable or unclear[11]”.

In response to this complex threat environment, the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor, Australia’s counter-terrorism law watchdog, is undertaking a landmark inquiry into Australia’s legal definition of terrorism[12]. Is it still fit for purpose?

The current definition

Australia’s legal definition of terrorism is found in section 100.1 of the Commonwealth Criminal Code[13]. It says conduct or a threat will qualify as a “terrorist act” if it satisfies these three requirements:

  • it is done to coerce or influence a government by intimidation, or intimidate a section of the public (intention requirement)

  • it is done for the purpose of advancing a political, religious or ideological cause (motive requirement)

  • it causes or relates to some specified harm, including death, serious bodily injury, serious property damage, or serious risks to health or safety (harm requirement).

There is an exemption for protest, advocacy, dissent or industrial action that is intended only to cause serious property damage.

This definition was created in 2002, following the September 11 attacks in the United States by al-Qaeda the previous year.

At that time, Australia did not have any national counter-terrorism laws. Countries around the world were scrambling to enact them in line with a resolution[14] adopted by the United Nations Security Council.

One country with laws already in place was the United Kingdom. Before September 11, the British Parliament enacted the Terrorism Act 2000[15], which was based on temporary and emergency powers used in Northern Ireland.

Australia and many other countries copied the UK’s definition in a rush. But we made some improvements, including the protest exemption.

More than two decades later, Australia’s definition of terrorism remains in its original form.

Why is the definition important?

Australia’s terrorism definition shapes a huge body of counter-terrorism laws. In fact, they are the world’s largest, with more than 100 statutes[16] and 5,000 pages of legal rules[17].

The starting point is the offence of committing a terrorist act. However, most prosecutions relate to various offences for support and preparation, which are triggered much earlier.

Just one example is an offence for advocating terrorism, which can be prosecuted when someone promotes or encourages terrorism on social media[18].

This definition also triggers special powers for surveillance, questioning, control orders, and preventative and continuing detention[19].

It even triggers powers unrelated to investigations. For example, in response to the Bondi terrorist attack in December last year, the NSW parliament enacted controversial new laws that allow the NSW police commissioner to ban protests[20] for up to three months after a declared terrorist act.

Given the number and scope of these offences and powers, it is crucial we have the best possible definition of terrorism on the statute books.

Is the definition fit for purpose?

The independent monitor’s inquiry will be extensive and detailed. At the heart of it will be questions about whether the motive requirement – that terrorism be done to “advance a political, religious or ideological cause” – appropriately captures current threats.

This requirement has long been controversial, mostly because it includes the word “religious”, which is said to fuel harmful discrimination[21] linking Islam and terrorism.

If the government removed religious motive from the definition, this would send an important signal that mainstream religion does not cause terrorism.

At the same time, it is doubtful how much a change to the legal wording would fix underlying community prejudices. More would be achieved by targeting problematic media reporting[22] and expanding community education.

Another argument against the motive requirement is that it doesn’t account well for mixed, unstable or unclear threats. New Zealand recently amended its definition[23] to say terrorism could be done “for one or more purposes”.

Australia’s wording doesn’t preclude there being multiple or mixed motives. However, a change along those lines would acknowledge the current threat environment.

A bigger issue is that the definition does not account for mass killings where ideology is unclear or absent.

This is where legal and community answers to the question “what is terrorism?” often diverge. The multiple stabbing attack in 2024 at Westfield Bondi Junction, for example, was not considered terrorism[24], even though it was a public mass killing that caused widespread community fear.

For those experiencing or witnessing the crisis and the wider community, there is little reason to distinguish that attack from terrorism. It makes no difference that the offender did not follow an ideology.

Legally speaking, however, there is a big difference between someone causing terror and someone intending to cause terror. Intention is a cornerstone of criminal law because it helps to determine moral responsibility.

Terrorism is fundamentally a communicative and ideological act[25]. If someone does not intend to communicate a message beyond the attack itself or seek change in line with a belief system, it is not terrorism.

For similar reasons, pure hate is difficult to fit within the terrorism laws. Even if it causes serious harm, hate crime is not always driven by an identifiable set of beliefs.

Removing the motive requirement altogether would mean mass killings that are purely hate-filled or where the ideology is unclear could be prosecuted more easily as terrorism.

However, this would drastically expand what currently counts as terrorism. It risks diluting the meaning of the word so it is even less clear.

For more than two decades, the motive requirement has distinguished terrorism from crimes that do not advance a belief system. Without it, there would be even greater overlap and confusion about what constitutes terrorism, murder, hate crime and many other offences.

We will know more later in the year about how the independent monitor approaches this key challenge for Australian law.

References

  1. ^ declared a terrorist act (www.abc.net.au)
  2. ^ coronial findings (www.smh.com.au)
  3. ^ extremism (theconversation.com)
  4. ^ Australia’s legal definition (theconversation.com)
  5. ^ neo-Nazis (theconversation.com)
  6. ^ incels (theconversation.com)
  7. ^ sovereign citizens (theconversation.com)
  8. ^ more (gnet-research.org)
  9. ^ Lone actors (theconversation.com)
  10. ^ mental health crises (www.theguardian.com)
  11. ^ mixed, unstable or unclear (theconversation.com)
  12. ^ inquiry into Australia’s legal definition of terrorism (www.inslm.gov.au)
  13. ^ Commonwealth Criminal Code (www.legislation.gov.au)
  14. ^ resolution (www.unodc.org)
  15. ^ Terrorism Act 2000 (www.legislation.gov.uk)
  16. ^ more than 100 statutes (www.inslm.gov.au)
  17. ^ 5,000 pages of legal rules (law.unimelb.edu.au)
  18. ^ encourages terrorism on social media (www.cdpp.gov.au)
  19. ^ continuing detention (theconversation.com)
  20. ^ ban protests (www.theguardian.com)
  21. ^ fuel harmful discrimination (www.inslm.gov.au)
  22. ^ problematic media reporting (news.griffith.edu.au)
  23. ^ definition (www.legislation.govt.nz)
  24. ^ not considered terrorism (www.abc.net.au)
  25. ^ communicative and ideological act (www.inslm.gov.au)

Authors: Keiran Hardy, Associate Professor, Griffith Criminology Institute, Griffith University

Read more https://theconversation.com/is-australias-terrorism-definition-still-fit-for-purpose-275309

The Weekend Times Magazine

How to Pay Off Your Mortgage Faster

Paying off the mortgage on your property early can save you significant amounts of money on interest Freeing yourself of the burden of having to keep up with monthly mortgage...

Australian holiday deals from Accor

For travellers looking to escape their cabin fever and embark on a holiday closer to home, Accor has released a range of state-by-state accommodation deals.   If you’re yearning for a change...

Should I get a COVID vaccine while I’m pregnant or breastfeeding?

From Monday, Australia’s front-line health workers, quarantine staff, border control officers, and workers and residents in aged-care homes will be offered the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine. Some of these workers will be...

CHECK.CHECK.CHECK. The new ‘Slip, Slop, Slap,’ for a night out campaign

CHECK.CHECK.CHECK. The new ‘Slip, Slop, Slap,’ for a night out launched by the Night Time Industries Association A new campaign Check. Check. Check. encouraging punters to do their...

The Biggest Mistakes People Make When Hiring Lawyers in Sydney

Choosing the right legal help can feel daunting, especially when time is short and the stakes feel high. Many people start by searching for lawyers in Sydney, then rely on...

Paid parental leave needs an overhaul if governments want us to have ‘one for the country’

As Australia and New Zealand face the realities of slow growth, or even a decline in population, it’s time to ask if their governments are doing enough. Especially if they...

What To Look For In a Robot Pool Cleaner

Robotic pool cleaners are a stunning feat of modern technology, allowing you to keep your pools clean with minimal effort on your part. Pool cleaning and maintenance has always remained...

Why Lighting Stores Perth Are the Key to Brightening Homes and Businesses

The right lighting can transform a room from dull to dynamic, highlight architectural details, and create an inviting environment for living, working, or entertaining. For those in Western Australia, visiting...

Why Sydney Never Stops Welcoming the World

Every weekend, Australia's harbour city reminds us why international tourism matters. Walk through Circular Quay on a Saturday morning and you'll hear dozens of languages before you've finished your coffee. Families photograph...

hacklink esim new zealandBetimgrandpashabet girişzlibraryz libraryjojobetcialis 20 mg fiyat