Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

Commercial space technology is shaping the Iran war – the law can’t keep up

  • Written by: Anna Marie Brennan, Senior Lecturer in Law, University of Waikato

When the United States and Israel launched Operation Epic Fury[1] against Iran nearly two weeks ago, the first confirmation didn’t come from governments. It came from commercial satellites.

Images from US companies Planet Labs and Vantor captured smoke billowing[2] over central Tehran and ships burning at the coastal city of Konarak – evidence of strikes on naval bases, airfields and missile sites that global media confirmed within hours.

But space-based technology was not just observing the conflict, it was also a target. US officials said early strikes hit “Iran’s equivalent of Space Command[3]”, undermining Tehran’s ability to coordinate via satellite.

Iran has also used extensive “spoofing”[4] to create false GPS signals to mislead receivers about their true location.

Simultaneously, US Space Command and Cyber Command launched operations[5] to jam, hack and disrupt Iranian software systems, known as “non-kinetic[6]” attacks in the jargon of modern warfare.

Such operations are a kind of “silent sabotage”, disabling communications or corrupting GPS signals without blowing anything up with conventional “kinetic” attacks[7].

This combination of advanced battlefield tactics and the rapid commercialisation of space technology, as well as the erosion of the old rules-based order[8] in general, means international law is now falling well behind.

Blurred lines of accountability

Non-kinetic tactics have quickly spilled into civilian life. In January, amid anti-government protests, and later during the first wave of strikes, Iran used GPS jamming and spoofing[9] to disrupt Starlink terminals[10], which civilians and protesters depended on to stay online and share information during internet blackouts.

At the same time, commercial satellite imagery became part of the conflict itself. After Planet Lab’s images revealed Iranian retaliatory strikes[11] on US and US-linked sites in the Persian Gulf, the company delayed releasing new imagery[12] to avoid aiding real‑time damage assessment by Iranian forces.

On March 10, Planet Labs extended the delay time[13] to two weeks for non-government users, but the US military still receives immediate access.

Modern warfare depends heavily[14] on these kinds of commercial, dual-use space systems. The same satellites that time financial transactions, support hospitals and manage global logistics also guide military operations.

This blurs the traditional legal boundary[15] between civilian and military objects and activities. The International Committee of the Red Cross has warned repeatedly[16] that interference with satellites can harm civilians by disrupting power grids, navigation, emergency services and humanitarian operations.

Outer space is not a legal vacuum. The United Nations’ Outer Space Treaty[17], the UN Charter[18] itself, and international humanitarian law[19] all apply to warfare in orbit. But the Iran war shows how real‑world practice is advancing faster than these legal frameworks.

A proper treaty is unlikely

Dual-use satellites providing both civilian broadband and military communications also complicate decisions[20] about what constitutes a lawful target.

Legal experts say satellites providing essential civilian services should be presumed to be non-military[21] unless direct military use is demonstrated. But this precept is tested daily over Iran.

Another challenge is political neutrality. If a private company based in a neutral state provides data that can assist military operations elsewhere, the neutral state may face serious questions[22] and diplomatic pressure[23] from other governments about whether it should be held responsible.

The law has not caught up with these commercial realities. Planet Lab’s imagery delays show how companies are having to improvise policy[24] themselves during armed conflict.

And because cyber-attacks can disable military systems without causing physical destruction, they can fall short[25] of “armed attack” thresholds under international law. States can exploit this legal grey zone to gain strategic advantage.

New legal norms may eventually evolve out of the behaviour of governments and commercial operators rather than through formal agreements and treaties. Indeed, geopolitical tensions make a new treaty on military space operations highly unlikely.

This leaves companies, regulators and militaries to define the boundaries of acceptable conduct through their real‑time responses. The result is a battlefield where satellites shape strategy faster than lawmakers can respond.

References

  1. ^ Operation Epic Fury (www.centcom.mil)
  2. ^ captured smoke billowing (www.nytimes.com)
  3. ^ Iran’s equivalent of Space Command (www.aljazeera.com)
  4. ^ also used extensive “spoofing” (edition.cnn.com)
  5. ^ launched operations (transcripts.cnn.com)
  6. ^ non-kinetic (www.raf.mod.uk)
  7. ^ conventional “kinetic” attacks (edition.cnn.com)
  8. ^ erosion of the old rules-based order (theconversation.com)
  9. ^ GPS jamming and spoofing (www.theguardian.com)
  10. ^ disrupt Starlink terminals (theconversation.com)
  11. ^ revealed Iranian retaliatory strikes (www.lemonde.fr)
  12. ^ delayed releasing new imagery (arstechnica.com)
  13. ^ extended the delay time (www.bloomberg.com)
  14. ^ depends heavily (doi.org)
  15. ^ blurs the traditional legal boundary (doi.org)
  16. ^ warned repeatedly (www.icrc.org)
  17. ^ Outer Space Treaty (www.unoosa.org)
  18. ^ UN Charter (www.un.org)
  19. ^ international humanitarian law (www.icrc.org)
  20. ^ complicate decisions (doi.org)
  21. ^ presumed to be non-military (doi.org)
  22. ^ serious questions (www.ejiltalk.org)
  23. ^ diplomatic pressure (www.bbc.com)
  24. ^ improvise policy (www.france24.com)
  25. ^ fall short (international-review.icrc.org)

Authors: Anna Marie Brennan, Senior Lecturer in Law, University of Waikato

Read more https://theconversation.com/commercial-space-technology-is-shaping-the-iran-war-the-law-cant-keep-up-277940

The Weekend Times Magazine

All the Things You Need to Know Before Flying to Cairns

Cairns is the gateway to Queensland, offering a tropical climate and a relaxing atmosphere, making it an ideal destination for outdoor activities. The city has iconic destinations, charming cafes, lively...

How pool putty can be a lifesaver when it comes to pool repairs

Pool putty is a great way to repair your pool. It works well for all types of repairs, especially when you need to patch up a hole in the liner...

Buying Your First Pontoon Boat? Here's What to Look For!

If you're a water lover and eager to cruise peaceful inland waterways more often, a pontoon boat is a great way to do it. Plus, it's largely considered the easiest...

Building a Custom Home on a Narrow Lot in Mandurah: What the Block Size Is Not Telling You

Property listings in Mandurah's established suburbs increasingly include lots that look modest on paper. Widths of 8, 10, or 12 metres. Street frontages that seem to leave little room for...

Dark Mode Emails: How to Design for Visibility and Impact

Image by DC Studio on Freepik With dark mode rolling out on various devices and email service providers, the need for emails to render correctly and legibly is vital. Dark mode...

The Best Luxury Cars in 2021

The best luxury cars that you can look out for this year. You are probably looking for the most comfortable car this year. You go for these types of cars...

What Happens During a Rental Property Inspection?

The rental property inspection is one main factor that sometimes leaves tenants wondering a lot of things. Though it might occasionally feel like a scary procedure, it is a lot...

Effective Pest Control Solutions in Ballarat: What You Need to Know

Living in Ballarat means enjoying a beautiful regional lifestyle, but it also comes with its share of challenges—one of which is managing pests. From termites threatening your home’s structure to...

How Legal Representation Helps Solve Family Disputes

Family disputes can be some of the most challenging legal matters individuals face. Issues involving separation, parenting arrangements, property division, and family responsibilities often involve both legal complexities and emotional...

hacklink esim new zealandBetimgrandpashabet girişzlibraryz libraryjojobetcialis 20 mg fiyat