Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

How and why NZ could be drawn into the Iran war – and the high stakes involved

  • Written by: Alexander Gillespie, Professor of Law, University of Waikato
How and why NZ could be drawn into the Iran war – and the high stakes involved

After three weeks of war in the Middle East, it is increasingly hard to predict what might happen next. But the prospect of a prolonged conflict has obvious and serious implications for New Zealand.

Beyond the impact of energy supply disruption and the economic consequences, there is the question of New Zealand military assistance to protect vital oil and gas shipments in the Strait of Hormuz.

On March 19, New Zealand joined a group of 19 countries[1] (including the United Kingdom, Canada and Australia) condemning Iran’s attacks on unarmed commercial vessels and declaring their “readiness to contribute to appropriate efforts to ensure safe passage through the Strait”.

The statement came after the United Nations Security Council issued Resolution 2817[2] on March 11 condemning the attacks by Iran against neighbouring Gulf states.

The Security Council also took note of the rights of member states, in accordance with international law (including the law of the sea), to defend their vessels from attack and actions that undermine navigational rights and freedoms.

Freedom of navigation – particularly around vital maritime routes[3] such as the Strait of Hormuz – is one of the oldest and most recognised legal principles. Indeed, it was partly why the United States was pulled into the first world war[4].

On March 22, NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte said[5] a group of 22 countries, including New Zealand, were “coming together” to secure the Strait of Hormuz. While there has been no formal commitment[6] from the government, nor has there been any statement against becoming involved.

Legal responses to an illegal war

By framing Iran’s actions as “a serious threat to international peace and security”, the Security Council effectively legitimised potential limited intervention by those 19 member states – which had so far resisted[7] US President Donald Trump’s unilateral attempts to draw them into his war.

In early 2024, New Zealand joined many of those countries to help protect shipping in the Red Sea[8] from attacks by Iran-backed Houthis in Yemen, part of their campaign against Israel’s devastation of Gaza[9].

The Houthis have now said[10] any expansion of the Iran conflict “will have negative consequences for supply chains, energy prices and the global economy as a whole”.

The sheer complexity, illegality and dangerous unpredictability of the entire situation means any practical commitment by New Zealand to assist will be a decision with serious domestic political implications in an election year.

It may be correct to defend a fundamental principle[11] of international law supported by the UN Security Council. But there is only a paper wall separating that decision from a war against Iran that didn’t comply with the UN Charter[12] in the first place.

The US and Israel have claimed their attack was an act of self-defence against Iran’s nuclear ambitions, which would be permitted under international law.

But it’s highly questionable whether the criteria for a justification of preemptive self defence was met. Only the International Court of Justice can definitively answer that.

The court is currently deliberating on the lawfulness of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, a case New Zealand strongly supports[13]. To be consistent, and if the opportunity arises, the government should apply the same standard and process to the US and Israel over Iran.

Lessons from history

Unfortunately, the legality of the justification for war is now being obscured by the illegal means by which it is being fought. An illegal attack has been met with illegal retaliation against regional noncombatants.

Iran is openly violating international humanitarian law[14] and the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea[15]. It has attacked dual-use civilian and military facilities (such as power plants) more for political and economic advantage than military gain.

And while international law protects civilians from attack or reprisal, it has had little effect in practice. Russia targets civilian areas and infrastructure in Ukraine, and Trump has threatened[16] to “obliterate” Iranian energy facilities (now postponed[17] after an original 48-hour deadline).

Both sides have carried out strikes[18] against or near nuclear facilities. The potential for this to become a humanitarian, environmental and economic disaster is clear.

New Zealand has little influence, however, beyond reminding all the belligerents – not just Iran – of their obligation to adhere to international humanitarian law.

But it must also be mindful of the lessons of recent history. Protecting the Strait of Hormuz may ultimately require “boots on the ground” to secure the coastline, not just the waterway.

As escalations from Vietnam to Iraq and Afghanistan have shown, such interventions can last decades, not weeks.

References

  1. ^ group of 19 countries (www.gov.uk)
  2. ^ Resolution 2817 (docs.un.org)
  3. ^ vital maritime routes (www.un.org)
  4. ^ pulled into the first world war (history.state.gov)
  5. ^ Mark Rutte said (wjla.com)
  6. ^ no formal commitment (www.rnz.co.nz)
  7. ^ so far resisted (www.theguardian.com)
  8. ^ protect shipping in the Red Sea (www.beehive.govt.nz)
  9. ^ campaign against Israel’s devastation of Gaza (www.cfr.org)
  10. ^ Houthis have now said (www.middleeastmonitor.com)
  11. ^ defend a fundamental principle (www.beehive.govt.nz)
  12. ^ didn’t comply with the UN Charter (theconversation.com)
  13. ^ New Zealand strongly supports (www.beehive.govt.nz)
  14. ^ violating international humanitarian law (ihl-databases.icrc.org)
  15. ^ UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (www.itlos.org)
  16. ^ Trump has threatened (www.npr.org)
  17. ^ postponed (www.npr.org)
  18. ^ carried out strikes (www.icanw.org)

Authors: Alexander Gillespie, Professor of Law, University of Waikato

Read more https://theconversation.com/how-and-why-nz-could-be-drawn-into-the-iran-war-and-the-high-stakes-involved-279083

The Weekend Times Magazine

Finding the Perfect Wedding Suit in Adelaide: Your Ultimate Guide

Your wedding day is one of the most important days of your life, and every detail matters. From the venue to the vows, everything should be perfect, especially your attire...

Why Carpet Cleaning Services Are Essential for Clean and Healthy Interiors

Clean carpets are a defining feature of comfortable and well-maintained interiors. Carpet cleaning services play an important role in preserving cleanliness, improving indoor comfort, and supporting healthier environments across residential and...

How TPD Solicitors Unlock Your Super Insurance Payout Fast

Up to 70% of Australians don't realize they have TPD insurance through their super, potentially missing out on life-changing payouts when they need them most. This staggering statistic reveals a...

Smart Lock: The Future of Home Security and Convenience

A smart lock has revolutionized the way people think about home security. Moving beyond traditional keys and mechanical locks, smart locks bring technology and convenience together, offering homeowners and businesses a new...

What Happens During a Rental Property Inspection?

The rental property inspection is one main factor that sometimes leaves tenants wondering a lot of things. Though it might occasionally feel like a scary procedure, it is a lot...

Why More Perth Homeowners Are Choosing Bidets for Modern Bathrooms

Bathroom renovations are no longer just about choosing stylish tiles, modern vanities and attractive tapware. Homeowners are increasingly considering how their bathrooms can support better hygiene, everyday comfort and long-term...

Could You Furnish and Equip a Whole House with IKEA Products?

IKEA has long been known as the global giant of affordable, ready-to-assemble furniture. From minimalist Scandinavian sofas to clever kitchen gadgets, the Swedish retailer has built its reputation on making...

Weekend getaways from Perth

You Are in Perth, Australia and You Want to Get Away for the Weekend: What Are the Options? Perth is one of the most isolated cities in the world, but that...

The best Nike shoes you can buy right now

You certainly have a few pairs of Nike sneakers around the house, but you may not be aware that the brand famous for its Swoosh was not always known as...

hacklink esim new zealandBetimgrandpashabet girişzlibraryz libraryjojobetcialis 20 mg fiyat