Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

Margaret Thornton on the landmark Tickle v Giggle transgender case

  • Written by: Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Last week, the Federal Court found[1] a transgender woman, Roxanne Tickle, had been directly discriminated against when she was removed from a women-only social media app, Giggle for Girls.

The historic decision[2] followed a long court saga, with the first judgement in 2024[3]. The app’s founder, Sall Grover, has said this week[4] she plans to appeal the “Giggle v Tickle” case in the High Court.

To unpack the case and its ongoing implications, we are joined on the podcast by Australian National University Emerita Professor Margaret Thornton[5]. She is an expert in gender equality, anti-discrimination law and feminist legal theory.

On Grover’s plan to appeal to the High Court, Thornton outlined why it was likely to proceed.

Appeals to the High Court are not automatic. But any appeal from Giggle and Tickle would almost certainly go ahead because it’s such an unusual issue, [the] first time that it’s been considered by an Australian court.

[…] How would the court decide? Who knows? But do note that four experienced federal court judges have already decided in favour of Ms Tickle on a fairly straightforward interpretation of the Sex Discrimination Act. And that would carry significant weight.

On the other hand, only three cases on sex gender discrimination have proceeded to the High Court in over 40 years, largely because of the cost of litigation is totally off putting to individuals.

Following the Federal Court’s ruling, Federal Opposition Leader Angus Taylor promised[6] a future Coalition government would legislate to clearly protect single sex spaces, based on biological sex, defined as a person’s sex at birth.

However, Thornton said this might break some of Australia’s international anti-discrimination obligations.

The convention[7] on the elimination of all forms of discrimination against women is really the primary [United Nations] instrument that underpins the [Australian] Sex Discrimination Act, and indeed gives it its constitutional basis.

So I think that would be a major issue. And it may well be something that the High Court would have to consider […] if they proceed with that appeal.

On others’ calls to restrict trans women from sports and women’s prisons, Thornton says the outcome of this court case isn’t likely to directly affect those issues.

The issue of sport is actually excluded from the Sex Discrimination Act, if it’s a case of the strength, stamina or physique of a person. But it continues to be controversial at the wider level.

And also I think that prisons are another ongoing site of contests. They’re not directly impacted. But some states, such as Victoria, I know are addressing the issue at the moment.

But the indirect effect of Giggle and Tickle could have the effect of encouraging a fairer and less stereotypical approach in these areas.

References

  1. ^ Federal Court found (www.fedcourt.gov.au)
  2. ^ historic decision (theconversation.com)
  3. ^ in 2024 (www.abc.net.au)
  4. ^ said this week (www.facebook.com)
  5. ^ Margaret Thornton (law.anu.edu.au)
  6. ^ promised (www.abc.net.au)
  7. ^ The convention (humanrights.gov.au)

Authors: Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Read more https://theconversation.com/politics-with-michelle-grattan-margaret-thornton-on-the-landmark-tickle-v-giggle-transgender-case-282993

The Weekend Times Magazine

How to work from home and not get divorced

Covid has triggered life-changing decisions for some people and has put a lot of relationship strain on couples. The stress of working from home and having to home school the...

Does Sydney Australia Have a Good Nightlife Scene?

In the last several years, Sydney's nightlife has changed dramatically. The New South Wales state government adopted Draconian lockout regulations in 2014, forcing city center venues to close their doors...

Choosing custom home builders in Perth: 7 questions to ask before you sign

Most people spend more time researching a new car than the builder who will spend the next year or more on their home. That is a costly imbalance. When you...

What to do in Canada during your holiday?

Canada has over 1.6 million square kilometers of protected natural land offering a world-class national park system. The country is one of the first in the world to establish a...

Box Mixers launches at home cocktail mixers

Box Mixers has announced its new range of zero alcohol cocktail mixers, made from all natural flavours, crafted to make drinking cocktails at home simple and convenient. Designed to appeal to...

The Hidden Financial World Most Australians Never See

Most Australians know their local bank. Few realise that an enormous financial market now operates largely behind the scenes. Private credit funds quietly finance office towers, apartment buildings, renewable energy projects, factories...

How To Gain Financial Freedom In Retirement

Planning for retirement? Retired already? Discover how you can gain financial independence during your golden years. Hitting retirement is a joyous milestone - a just reward for a lifetime of hard...

What is Medicines Optimisation and Why is it Important?

Medicines optimisation is a patient-focused approach to safe and effective medication use that helps people get the best possible outcomes from their treatments. Rather than simply ensuring patients take their...

The Most Popular Tattoo Placements (and Why)

Choosing where to place your tattoo is almost as important as choosing the artwork itself. Placement affects how a tattoo looks, how it heals, how visible it is in day-to-day...

hacklink Betimgrandpashabet resmi girişzlibraryz library