Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

Australia has ruled out repatriation for ISIS families. This isn’t a safe or coherent plan

  • Written by: Se Youn Park, Sessional academic, School of Political Science and International Studies, The University of Queensland

Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said his government will not help repatriate the 34 Australian women and children with links to Islamic State fighters who were released from a detention camp in Syria and are reportedly trying[1] to return to Australia.

The women and children were among more than 2,000 people from 50 different countries detained at al-Roj camp in Kurdish-controlled northern Syria. The Australians were turned back by Syrian officials when trying to reach Damascus this week, with the goal of returning to Australia.

The Albanese government’s stance on the Australian women and children in Syria has never really been clarified, which is fuelling all of this uncertainty at the moment.

There’s a precedent for repatriation

Australia has demonstrated it can repatriate[2] its citizens safely when it feels compelled to. In 2022, for example, it helped repatriate four women – the wives and widows of IS militants – and their 13 children from al-Roj camp in Syria.

Australia has ruled out repatriation for ISIS families. This isn’t a safe or coherent plan
Women and children walk among tents at al-Roj camp in northeastern Syria. Baderkhan Ahmad/AP

It has also acknowledged that if citizens return independently from conflict zones, security agencies[3] are capable of investigating and managing any risks.

Yet, it has not established a permanent framework for when and how such returns should occur.

Instead, Australia continues to rely on ad hoc decision-making shaped by individual circumstances, rather than a solid plan. This case-by-case approach[4] has produced uneven and opaque outcomes.

Take for example the four women repatriated in 2022. What happened next remains only partially known. One of the women, Mariam Raad[5], was prosecuted in Australia for entering Islamic State-controlled territory. She pleaded guilty, but was discharged without conviction and placed on a good behaviour bond.

Others, including Mariam Dabboussy[6], returned and resettled in the community. Yet, there is little publicly available information about their legal situations, monitoring arrangements or long-term reintegration plans.

This opacity makes it difficult to assess whether Australia is applying consistent legal standards or managing risk systematically.

Mitigating risks through managed returns

The ambiguity here reflects a broader pattern of political caution and strategic delay.

For years, Australian governments framed the repatriation of citizens who had travelled to Syria or Iraq as an unacceptable security risk. They relied on citizenship revocation and political refusal to prevent it.

In 2022, however, the High Court limited[7] the government’s power to revoke citizenship, removing one of these key tools.

At the same time, the conditions in the Syrian detention camps deteriorated, heightening international pressure on countries to repatriate their citizens trapped there.

These factors eventually forced a shift in Australia’s stance, resulting in the 2022 repatriation. However, this shift was never institutionalised.

In 2024, then-Home Affairs Minister Clare O'Neil seemed set to do this by preparing a plan[8] to repatriate the remaining women and children. However, this plan was shelved and never revisited.

As a result, the problem has been deferred rather than resolved. This weakens Australia’s ability to manage the possible security risk posed by these women effectively. Leaving citizens in overseas detention does not eliminate risk. It just makes it somebody else’s problem.

When individuals remain in foreign camps, Australian authorities cannot monitor them effectively, prosecute them or support their disengagement from radical ideologies. This limits our intelligence capabilities and our ability to track former members and the potential threat they pose.

Avoiding repatriation does not prevent their return, either. It just makes returns harder to manage.

Some allies have a different approach

Last October, two Australian women and their four children escaped a camp in Syria and made their own way to Lebanon. Once at the Australian embassy, they were given passports[9] to return to Australia.

When individuals return through informal pathways such as this, authorities have less time to prepare and fewer opportunities to implement structured legal, monitoring and reintegration measures. It’s also far more dangerous for the people involved.

Many of Australia’s allies have recognised this reality.

The United States[10] has actively encouraged Western countries[11] to repatriate their citizens in the name of global security. It’s even offered military assistance[12] to do so.

Several European governments[13] have also begun repatriating women and children with more urgency.

Countries such as the Netherlands[14] and Germany[15] have implemented planned repatriation programmes linked to judicial processes and long-term supervision. These governments recognise that repatriation is not a concession. It is a security management strategy.

France, too, which had long been hesitant to repatriate its nationals from Syria, shifted from a “case-by-case” approach[16] in 2022 after facing criticism from the European Court of Human Rights and the UN Committee Against Torture.

Responsibility to protect

There is also a deeper legal issue at stake. Many Australian women detained in Syria have been held for years without charge or trial. By leaving citizens in indefinite offshore detention, Australia risks undermining its commitment to due process and the rule of law.

The choice is not between security and accountability. It is between managing citizens within Australia’s legal system or leaving them in unstable environments where Australia has no oversight.

The question is no longer whether Australian women and children will return. It is whether Australia will manage their return deliberately, or continue responding only after events force its hand.

References

  1. ^ reportedly trying (www.abc.net.au)
  2. ^ repatriate (www.smh.com.au)
  3. ^ security agencies (www.abc.net.au)
  4. ^ case-by-case approach (drive.google.com)
  5. ^ Mariam Raad (www.abc.net.au)
  6. ^ Mariam Dabboussy (www.theguardian.com)
  7. ^ limited (www.news.com.au)
  8. ^ preparing a plan (www.theguardian.com)
  9. ^ they were given passports (www.theage.com.au)
  10. ^ United States (www.theguardian.com)
  11. ^ encouraged Western countries (www.state.gov)
  12. ^ military assistance (www.theage.com.au)
  13. ^ European governments (icct.nl)
  14. ^ Netherlands (icct.nl)
  15. ^ Germany (www.aljazeera.com)
  16. ^ shifted from a “case-by-case” approach (www.lemonde.fr)

Authors: Se Youn Park, Sessional academic, School of Political Science and International Studies, The University of Queensland

Read more https://theconversation.com/australia-has-ruled-out-repatriation-for-isis-families-this-isnt-a-safe-or-coherent-plan-276160

The Weekend Times Magazine

Weekend Escapes Closer to Home: Making the Most of Every Litre

Rising fuel prices are changing more than household budgets—they are changing the way Australians holiday. For many families, a weekend away has traditionally meant filling the car and heading several hundred...

Building Designer in Melbourne: Crafting Innovative, Functional, and Sustainable Spaces

In a city celebrated for its architectural excellence and diverse urban character, the role of a building designer Melbourne has never been more important. Melbourne’s built environment is a dynamic blend...

The Most Popular Tattoo Placements (and Why)

Choosing where to place your tattoo is almost as important as choosing the artwork itself. Placement affects how a tattoo looks, how it heals, how visible it is in day-to-day...

What to Consider When Choosing a Shopify web developer

Choosing a development partner should begin with a clear understanding of what the online store needs to achieve. A Shopify web developer can help translate products, customers, business processes and technical requirements...

Prime Minister Press Conference Australian Parliament House

PRIME MINISTER: Good afternoon everyone. Today's meeting of the National Cabinet came during a week of what I'd describe of increased hope. This was a week of hope. We were...

The 2026 Backyard Trends Rowville Homeowners Are Actually Building

Spend a Saturday morning around Stud Park and you'll hear it from half the streets nearby: a drill, a truck reversing, a family debating where the barbecue should go. Rowville's...

Australia’s Booming Cosmetic Dentistry Market: What Patients Are Asking For in 2025

Cosmetic dentistry in Australia is experiencing an unprecedented boom, with more patients than ever seeking to enhance their smiles through innovative and accessible treatments. The landscape of aesthetic dentistry has...

Why Removalists Melbourne Are the Smartest Choice for an Easy and Organised Move

Relocating from one home or office to another can feel overwhelming, especially when you’re trying to balance packing, sorting, transporting, and managing deadlines all at once. Choosing experienced removalists Melbourne is...

Why More Perth Homeowners Are Choosing Bidets for Modern Bathrooms

Bathroom renovations are no longer just about choosing stylish tiles, modern vanities and attractive tapware. Homeowners are increasingly considering how their bathrooms can support better hygiene, everyday comfort and long-term...

hacklink esim new zealandBetimgrandpashabet girişzlibraryz libraryjojobetcialis 20 mg fiyat